Abstract

Mitochondrial diseases are complex disorders that exhibit their primary effects in energetically active tissues. Damage generated by mitochondria is also thought to be a key component of aging and age-related disease. An important model for mitochondrial dysfunction is the bang sensitive (bs) mutants in Drosophila melanogaster. Although these mutants all show a striking seizure phenotype, several bs mutants have gene products that are involved with mitochondrial function, while others affect excitability another way. All of the bs mutants (parabss, eas, jus, ses B, tko are examined here) paralyze and seize upon challenge with a sensory stimulus, most notably mechanical stimulation. These and other excitability mutants have been linked to neurodegeneration with age. In addition to these phenotypes, we have found age-related defects for several of the bs strains. The mutants eas, ses B, and tko display shortened lifespan, an increased mean recovery time from seizure with age, and decreased climbing ability over lifespan as compared to isogenic CS or w1118 lines. Other mutants show a subset of these defects. The age-related phenotypes can be rescued by feeding melatonin, an antioxidant, in all the mutants except ses B. The age-related defects do not appear to be correlated with the seizure phenotype. Inducing seizures on a daily basis did not exacerbate the phenotypes and treatment with antiepileptic drugs did not increase lifespan. The results suggest that the excitability phenotypes and the age-related phenotypes may be somewhat independent and that these phenotypes mutants may arise from impacts on different pathways.

As a cellular organelle, mitochondria are well understood, however, their role in generating system level effects that lead to malfunctioning tissues or disease is less well defined. In humans, mitochondrial DNA mutations are regularly associated with a wide range of specific defects, affecting tissues with high energy needs, such as the heart, brain, muscles, and sensorineural epithelia (Toivonen et al. 2001). Phenotypically, these mutations manifest themselves as hearing loss, dementia, loss of cognitive and/or motor skills, paralysis, and/or seizure. Myoclonic epilepsy associated with ragged-red muscle fibers (MERRF), have been shown to be a product of mitochondrial mutations (Wallace et al. 1988; Shoffner et al. 1990). Various neurodegenerative diseases including Parkinson’s disease have been linked to mutations in mitochondrial genes in either the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) or the nuclear DNA (nDNA) (Wallace 2001). Even normal mitochondrial function damages cells over time and this accumulated damage is thought to contribute to the aging process (Askenova et al. 1998; Cossarizza and Salvioli 2001; López-Otın et al. 2016). Previous work with Drosophila has shown that overexpression of SOD retards oxidative damage by preventing ROS build-up that results in a longer lifespan (Sohal et al. 1995). Mitochondrial mutants may be even more likely to contribute to the build-up of ROS that might result in a shorter lifespan than the normal fly (Kurzik-Dumke et al. 1998).

Bang sensitive (bs) mutants are means to study the connections between mitochondrial dysfunction, neurological disease and aging. The bs mutants were first characterized because of their phenotype: bs mutants paralyze and seize upon receiving a short mechanical shock or “bang.” (Benzer 1971; Ganetzky and Wu 1982). Several bs mutants have been described (Table 1). When a mechanical bang is applied, these mutants first seize briefly, then remain paralyzed for anywhere between 5 and 30 sec, then seize violently for a few seconds, and at this point are able to right themselves. Seizure is classified as coordinated contraction of all muscle sets within the fly (Pavlidis and Tanouye 1995; Lee and Wu 2002). In these mutants, seizure susceptibility is enhanced as compared to wildtype (Kuebler and Tanouye 2000).

Mutants that display bang sensitive behavior and their protein product

Table 1
Mutants that display bang sensitive behavior and their protein product
Gene NameProtein ProductReferences
technical knockout (tko)Mitochondrial ribosomal proteinRoyden et al. (1987)
stress-sensitive B (ses B)Mitochondrial adenine nucleotide translocaseZhang et al. (1999)
easily shocked (eas)Ethanolamine kinase mitochondrialPavlidis et al. (1994)
paralyzedbss1 (bss) formerly known as bangsenselessPara sodium channelParker et al. (2011)
julius seizure (jus) formerly known as slamdanceUnknown gene functionZhang et al. (2002a); Horne et al. (2017)
knockdown (kdn)Mitochondrial citrate synthaseFergestad et al. (2006b)
bang-sensitive (bas)unknownBurg and Wu (2012)
Gene NameProtein ProductReferences
technical knockout (tko)Mitochondrial ribosomal proteinRoyden et al. (1987)
stress-sensitive B (ses B)Mitochondrial adenine nucleotide translocaseZhang et al. (1999)
easily shocked (eas)Ethanolamine kinase mitochondrialPavlidis et al. (1994)
paralyzedbss1 (bss) formerly known as bangsenselessPara sodium channelParker et al. (2011)
julius seizure (jus) formerly known as slamdanceUnknown gene functionZhang et al. (2002a); Horne et al. (2017)
knockdown (kdn)Mitochondrial citrate synthaseFergestad et al. (2006b)
bang-sensitive (bas)unknownBurg and Wu (2012)
Table 1
Mutants that display bang sensitive behavior and their protein product
Gene NameProtein ProductReferences
technical knockout (tko)Mitochondrial ribosomal proteinRoyden et al. (1987)
stress-sensitive B (ses B)Mitochondrial adenine nucleotide translocaseZhang et al. (1999)
easily shocked (eas)Ethanolamine kinase mitochondrialPavlidis et al. (1994)
paralyzedbss1 (bss) formerly known as bangsenselessPara sodium channelParker et al. (2011)
julius seizure (jus) formerly known as slamdanceUnknown gene functionZhang et al. (2002a); Horne et al. (2017)
knockdown (kdn)Mitochondrial citrate synthaseFergestad et al. (2006b)
bang-sensitive (bas)unknownBurg and Wu (2012)
Gene NameProtein ProductReferences
technical knockout (tko)Mitochondrial ribosomal proteinRoyden et al. (1987)
stress-sensitive B (ses B)Mitochondrial adenine nucleotide translocaseZhang et al. (1999)
easily shocked (eas)Ethanolamine kinase mitochondrialPavlidis et al. (1994)
paralyzedbss1 (bss) formerly known as bangsenselessPara sodium channelParker et al. (2011)
julius seizure (jus) formerly known as slamdanceUnknown gene functionZhang et al. (2002a); Horne et al. (2017)
knockdown (kdn)Mitochondrial citrate synthaseFergestad et al. (2006b)
bang-sensitive (bas)unknownBurg and Wu (2012)

Some of the bs genes have been shown to encode for nuclear products involved in mitochondrial function, while the other mutants do not appear, at least directly, to affect this organelle (Table 1). The bs gene technical knockout (tko) product is a mitochondrial ribosomal protein that affects protein synthesis in the mitochondria and stress sensitive B (ses B) encodes a mitochondrial adenine nucleotide translocase (Royden et al. 1987; Shah et al. 1997; Zhang et al. 1999). The knockdown (kdn) gene encodes citrate synthase (Fergestad et al. 2006b). Another bs gene, easily shocked (eas) gene encodes ethanolamine kinase, an enzyme involved in de novo synthesis of phosphotidyl-ethanolamine, which occurs within the mitochondria (Pavlidis et al. 1994). Decreased ATP levels have been observed in eas, ses B and tko mutants (Fergestad et al. 2006b). Other bs mutant do not appear to affect mitochondrial function directly. The bs mutant paralyzedbss (abbreviated as bss for the remainder of this paper) is an allele of the Na channel gene, while the cellular role of julius seizure remains unclear (Parker et al. 2011; Horne et al. 2017,). However, all of these strains of bs mutants show very similar, if not identical, neurological phenotypes. The behavioral data leads to the idea that all the bs mutations could affect mitochondrial function, structure, or location within the organism. Several investigators have asked if other mitochondrial enzymes produce bs phenotypes, but genes for glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase, arginase, and proline oxidase and other Kreb cycle enzymes do not have alleles that show bs phenotypes (Wang et al. 2004; Fergestad et al. 2006b).

In this paper, we document age-related aspects of a subset of the bs mutants and explore the relationship of aging phenotypes to their seizure behavior. We looked at the lifespan of bs flies, evaluated their seizure phenotype with age, and looked at their climbing ability. Defects in climbing ability have been correlated with neurodegeneration (Feany and Bender 2000). We also attempted to rescue the age-related phenotypes with melatonin and anti-epileptic drugs (AEDs). Our data suggests that the neurological phenotype and age-related phenotypes are somewhat separable. The antioxidant melatonin relieves age-related declines in some mutants, while having no impact on epileptic seizure in young flies. Although AEDs were previously observed to decrease seizure frequency (Reynolds et al. 2004), the drugs have no effect on lifespan. These experiments lead to a better understanding of tissue-specific dysfunction and disease.

Materials And Methods

Fly Stocks

All stocks were maintained on a standard yeast, cornmeal, molasses food at 21-25° unless otherwise noted. Flies were transferred at regular intervals to maintain continuous cultures of the strains used. For all experiments, flies were kept in a humidified, temperature-controlled environment at 25° throughout and kept on a 12 hr light/dark schedule (Rogina, Benzer, & Helfand 1997). Stocks for tko, bss f and eas f were originally isolated on a CS background and have been isogenized with CS through 10 generations. CS was used as the control for these strains. We also generated w1118 tko, w1118 bss f and w1118 eas f stocks and these stocks were used to confirm some behavioral data and for the cytochrome oxidase assays described below. Stocks for jus and ses B originated from a white background and were compared to w1118 stock as a control. For all of these genes, there is only one allele that displays the seizures and age-related defects, although they do so in different genetic backgrounds. All stocks are negative for Wolbachia infection as determined by PCR analysis (Grandison et al. 2009). All stocks and other reagents used in these experiments are included in a Reagent Table as a supplemental file (see Reagent and Data Availability below).

Lifespan Study

All experiments looking at the lifespan of a population of flies were conducted in the same general fashion. Ten female and ten male flies were transferred to plastic bottles containing a standard food, with several grains of yeast added on top and allowed to lay eggs for 5 days. From these cultures, 100 adult flies were collected from 0-5 days and maintained in a bottle containing standard food. Survivors were transferred to new food within every 5-day interval and dead flies were counted. There were at least three replicate bottles for each experiment. Mean survival percent and standard deviations were calculated for each strain from data points within the five-day age brackets. Pairwise comparisons were made with controls using T tests with significance at P < 0.05.

Phenotype Over Lifespan Study

Ten female and ten male flies of the strain to be tested were transferred to standard food with several grains of yeast added and allowed to lay eggs for 5 days. Young hatching flies were collected using anesthesia at 5 days of age and maintained in groups of 15-20 flies in a vial containing standard food. During every 5-day interval of the lifespan, the flies were placed into a clean empty vial and rested for 20 min. Bang sensitivity was measured by vortexing each vial of flies for 10 sec at a maximum speed. Recovery time for individual flies was then recorded. Data were collected from at least 3 replicate vials in each experiment and the whole experiment was repeated twice. Mean recovery time and standard deviations were calculated for each strain from data points within the five-day age brackets. Comparisons were made with controls using T tests with significance at P < 0.05.

Climbing Assays

Flies used in the climbing assay were raised and maintained as described for the phenotype study. During every 5-day interval of the lifespan, the flies were placed into a clean empty vial and rested for 20 min. Flies from each vial then gently tapped to the bottom of the vial. The number of flies that climbed above a line 4 cm from the top of the vial was counted after 20 sec (Feany & Bender 2000). Occasional, especially later in the lifespan, a few flies would paralyze due to the tap. However, the number that paralyzed in any given experiment was small and these flies were excluded from that climbing data point. The process was repeated 5 times with a two-minute rest period between trials to determine an average for the data point. For initial experiments, after allowing the vials to rest for 20 min, the climbing assay was repeated. The second assay was dropped in later experiments after it was determined that the data collected at both times were statistically the same. The mean percentage of flies to cross the line in 20 sec and standard deviations for each time point were calculated for each strain. Strains at various time points were compared using t-tests with significance at P < 0.05.

Melatonin and Antiepileptic Drugs Studies

Ten males and ten females were placed into a plastic bottle standard food containing 100μg/ml melatonin (Sigma, St. Louis, MO) and allowed to lay eggs for 5 days. A control culture was also raised without the drug. At 5 days of age, flies reared on the melatonin-infused food and the control were collected and placed in plastic bottles containing the same food mixture. The effect of melatonin as compared to the control on lifespan, phenotype and climbing ability of the bs strains was determined using the procedures outline above.

In a similar fashion the effect of the antiepileptic drugs phenytoin and valproate was tested on the lifespan of one bs strain, easily shocked (eas). Various doses of the drugs were examined by raising both CS and eas in standard fly food infused with the drugs. Flies were maintained on the drug during their lifespan. These doses had previously been shown to reduce the antiepileptic phenotype of this strain at 5 days of age as evidence by a reduction in the MRT and the percentage of flies paralyzed (Kuebler and Tanouye 2002; Reynolds et al. 2004). For each drug and each dose, three replicate bottles were performed and the experiment was repeated three times. Lifespan data were collected and analyzed as described above.

Seizure and Lifespan Experiments

Experiments looking for an effect of seizure on lifespan were conducted in the same fashion as other lifespan experiments except that the initial number of flies per bottles was 40. Each day during the lifespan study, flies were transferred without anesthesia to a clear vial and then vortexed for 10 sec. After recovery, flies were then transferred back to the holding bottle. Lifespan data were collected and analyzed as described above.

Mitochondrial Isolation and Cytochrome C Oxidase Assay

Flies were collected either 5 days (young) or 15 days (old) after eclosion. One hundred flies were homogenized in 1.5 mL of PBS using a Tissue Tearor (Thomas Scientific, Swedesboro, NJ). Mitochondria were isolated per kit instructions (Thermoscientific, Rockford, IL). The pellet was resuspended in 200 ul of PBS then sonicated on ice. The samples were stored at -80 C until testing. Cytochrome C oxidase is an enzyme associated with the electron transport chain of mitochondria. Assays were preformed as directed by a cytochrome C oxidase assay kit (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, Missouri) as per instructions. Briefly, reduced cytochrome C was generated by reducing Ferrocytochrome C (FCC) by the addition of DTT and incubation until the 550/565 ratio was at least 10. Each assay contained appropriate amounts of assay buffer, enzyme buffer, reduced cytochrome C, and 50 ul of the mitochondrial isolate. All absorbance was read immediately at 550nm for the first 45 sec of the reaction. Enzyme activity was calculated by looking at the change in absorbance over the time interval and using the change in extinction coefficient between the oxidized and reduced state to estimate the amount of activity per ul of sample. Activity was reported as U/mg based on a standard BCA protein assay (Markwell et al. 1981). At least three assays were preformed independently for each strain and time point. Comparisons were made with controls using T tests with significance at P < 0.05.

Reagent and Data Availability Statement

All reagents and data from this work are available. The reagents used including fly stocks and kits are listed in the Reagent Table provided as a supplemental file FileS1. Fly stocks are available from the author. All the data collected for these experiments is available as supplemental file FileS2. Supplemental files available at FigShare. Supplemental material available at Figshare: https://doi.org/10.25387/g3.6860309.

Results

Lifespan Study

If one compares the day at which 50% of flies survive, CS, w118, jus and bss are not significantly different (41 days, 37 days, 40 days and 37.5 days respectively), while eas, tko and ses B have significantly shorter times to that 50% population mark (29 days, 25 days and 22 days respectively). The mitochondrial mutants, tko and ses B, both showed a dramatic reduction in lifespan vs. the control strains (Figure 1A, CS is shown, CS-w118 P > 0.1). By 30 days of age, every fly in the ses B population had died, while the wildtype had 70 ± 15.2% of its population remaining. The tko flies had no survivors by 45 days of age, while CS had 42 ± 6% of the population alive. Both the tko and ses B flies showed a significant reduction in the survival percent by 11-15 day range (CS-tko P = 0.0027, CS-ses B P = 0.0011). The eas strain also showed a decrease in lifespan as compared to the control with significance being reached at 21 days of age (P = 0.0426) and with no survival past 55 days of age (Figure 1A). The bss or the jus population, however, did not show a significant reduction in lifespan vs. the control at any age. Comparisons were also made with tko, eas and bss mutants crossed into a w1118 background. The same results were observed; tko and eas showed reduced lifespans compared to the w control (data not shown).

Figure 1

Lifespan and age-related phenotypes for bang sensitive mutants. A) Lifespan B) Mean Recovery Time C) Climbing ability . All error bars are presented as standard deviations.

Other Age-related Phenotypes

Over their lifespan, all of the bs strains except jus showed a dramatic worsening of the bang-sensitive phenotype, as characterized by an increase in mean recovery time (Figure 1B). The decline occurred at a similar rate for the affected strains. The eas strain showed the largest change with age, beginning with a 94 ± 25 s recovery time and ending with a 585 ± 90 s recovery time at 41 days of age (P < 0.001). The ses B, tko and bss strains also showed increases in recovery times: ses B from an initial 151 ± 56 s recovery time to 491 ± 74 s recovery time by 16 days old; tko from an initial 100 ± 30 s recovery time to 327 ± 75 s recovery time by 35 days of age; and bss from a 188 ± 65s initial recovery time to a 658 ± 209 s recovery time at 36 days of age. The control CS or w strains do not exhibit a bang-sensitive phenotype over their lifespan.

All mutants also showed a significant decrease in climbing ability with age (Figure 1C). The mutant strains ses B and bss were found to have a decreased ability to climb from an early age. All other mutants demonstrated initial climbing abilities equivalent to the wild type. By 30 days of age, all bs flies showed a significant reduction in climbing ability as compared to the normal fly (P < 0.001). Wild type flies showed a gradual decrease in climbing ability with age.

We also look at cytochrome oxidase activity over age for w, and bss, tko and eas mutant stains in a w background (Table 2). Cytochrome oxidase activity is part of Complex IV of the electron transport chain that delivers the electrons to oxygen and its activity is highly correlated with overall mitochondrial function. We found that tko and bss had significantly higher levels of cytochrome oxidase in both 5 and 15 day old flies (w vs. tko P < 0.004 for both, w vs. bss P < 0.02 for both), but the mutant eas had no significant difference in cytochrome oxidase activity. We also performed assays on sesB, but the variability of individual experiments was large and so the data were difficult to interpret (data not shown). Over that time frame, there was no difference in cytochrome oxidase with age for the control or mutant strains.

Cytochrome Oxidase Data at 5 and 15 days

Table 2
Cytochrome Oxidase Data at 5 and 15 days
Strain5 days U/mg15 days U/mg
w11188.78 ± 1.368.18 ± 0.61
w1118tko15.74 + 3.1514.15 + 2.17
w1118eas9.06 + 3.066.36 + 1.44
w1118bss19.00 + 2.3220.27 + 1.69
Strain5 days U/mg15 days U/mg
w11188.78 ± 1.368.18 ± 0.61
w1118tko15.74 + 3.1514.15 + 2.17
w1118eas9.06 + 3.066.36 + 1.44
w1118bss19.00 + 2.3220.27 + 1.69
Table 2
Cytochrome Oxidase Data at 5 and 15 days
Strain5 days U/mg15 days U/mg
w11188.78 ± 1.368.18 ± 0.61
w1118tko15.74 + 3.1514.15 + 2.17
w1118eas9.06 + 3.066.36 + 1.44
w1118bss19.00 + 2.3220.27 + 1.69
Strain5 days U/mg15 days U/mg
w11188.78 ± 1.368.18 ± 0.61
w1118tko15.74 + 3.1514.15 + 2.17
w1118eas9.06 + 3.066.36 + 1.44
w1118bss19.00 + 2.3220.27 + 1.69

Effects of Melatonin on Age-related Phenotypes

In separate experiments, bang sensitive mutants that showed a reduction in lifespan (tko, ses B, and eas) were raised with melatonin, a known free radical scavenger, in an attempt to investigate whether the age-related phenotypes could linked with increased ROS in the mutants. The melatonin increased the lifespan in all mutant stains, except ses B (P > 0.8 for all time points) (Figure 2A). Comparing the 50% survival point for each strain, CS (54 days vs. 41 days), eas (44 days vs. 30 days), and tko (48 days vs. 24 days) had longer lifespans on melatonin, while ses B showed little difference (25 days vs. 23 days). The effect on tko was dramatic: without melatonin flies were all dead by the age of 45, while 45 ± 1.2% of the tko melatonin flies were alive at that same age. In a similar fashion, eas mutants raised with melatonin had a 55 ± 2% survival at 50 days of age, while all eas flies raised without melatonin were dead by 50 days of age.

Figure 2

Lifespan and age-related phenotypes for selected bang sensitive mutants with melatonin supplementation. A) Lifespan B) Mean Recovery Time. All error bars are presented as standard deviations.

Melatonin supplementation significantly reduced the effect of age on recovery time for the tko and eas mutants but not for ses B (Figure 2B). The initial recovery time at 5 days of age for control tko mutants was 100 ± 30 s, while the initial recovery time for melatonin raised tko flies was 60 ± 31 s. By the 35 day age bracket, the control tko flies took 327 ± 41 s to fully recover, while the melatonin tko mutants only took 88 ± 72.5 s to recover during the same age range. The melatonin raised eas population also showed a striking reduction in recovery time, especially later in their lifespan (P = 0.0114). By 40 days of age, the control eas flies took an average of 465 ± 46 s to recover, but the melatonin eas population needed an average of 154 ± 65 s for recovery. The melatonin-supplemented ses B and control ses B strains did not show any significant difference in recovery times at any point in their lifespan (P = 0.1335). Melatonin supplementation also had an impact on recovery time on the bss mutant, which previously was shown to have an increasing MRT with age (data not shown in Figure 2). At 40 days of age, the control bss population had a mean recovery time of 658 ± 209 s; in contrast, the melatonin-raised population had a mean recovery time of 145 ± 44 s at 40 days old. While melatonin supplementation did improve significantly the initial MRT of several mutants, seizure was not completely eradicated in any bang sensitive mutant. These melatonin results suggest that some bs mutants might have age-related phenotypes mediated by ROS, but that some mutants like ses B cannot simply be rescued by a reduction in ROS levels.

Effects of Anti-epileptic Drugs on Age-related Phenotypes

It could be that the hyperexcitability produced by bs mutants leads to degeneration or other declines in nervous system function that result in the reduced lifespan. We designed two different experiments to look at the relationship between hyperexcitability or seizure and decreased lifespan. First we asked if generating a seizure everyday using mechanical shock could lead to a decreased lifespan. While there was a slight decrease in lifespan with daily mechanical stress, the decrease was also observed in wildtype and is likely to physical damage accumulated by vortexing (Figure 3A).

Figure 3

Decreased lifespan is not related to epileptic phenotype. A) Flies were vortexed every five days over lifespan B) Flies were treated with phenytoin as indicated. C) Flies were treated with valproate as indicated. All error bars are presented as standard deviations.

In previous work, it had been shown that several antiepileptic drugs decreased the percentage of seizure in bs mutant flies as well as the time necessary to recover from seizure (Kuebler and Tanouye 2002; Reynolds et al. 2004). We treated the bs mutants with various concentrations of the antiepileptic drugs phenytoin and valproate for their effects on lifespan. Surprisingly, the drugs had very little effect on lifespan. Figure 3B and C show the lifespan data for phenytoin and valproate respectively for the eas mutant, which had shown the strongest drug effect in previous work. The administration of phenytoin and valproate throughout development at several doses did not rescue the defects in lifespan for eas mutants. Overall, these results do not support the hypothesis that the behavioral phenotype and the age-related defects are functionally related.

Discussion

This study found that lifespan was altered in several bang-sensitive mutants, and that the seizure phenotype and climbing ability became worse with age. A summary of the age-related phenotypes of the mutants is presented in Table 3. Previous studies have demonstrated that both the tko and ses B strains have mutations in the gene that encodes for nuclear mitochondrial products (Royden et al. 1987; Shah et al. 1997; Zhang et al. 1999). The vital role that mitochondria play in the basic energy production in all tissues posits that any mitochondrial defect might produce physiological and behavioral changes. The defects in mitochondrial mutants tko and ses B, in addition to bs behavior, produced a reduced lifespan, worsening of the bang-sensitive phenotype with age, and a decrease in climbing ability with age. The tko mutation affects a mitochondrial ribosome protein and has a broader impact on mitochondrial function, while the ses B mutation affects the mitochondrial adenine nucleotide translocase genes. Some authors have suggested that both mutants have strong impacts on energy production (Fergestad et al. 2006b; Kemppainen et al. 2016). Toivonen et al. (2001) show that tko impacts a number of mitochondrial complex enzymes in contrast to our study, which finds a slight increase in cytochrome oxidase function as compared to control. Our findings are supported by another study, which shows that mitochondrial mutants compensate for their energetic losses (Celotto et al. 2011). In addition, Kemppainen et al. (2014) found that tko is not rescued by an alternative oxidase, which should alleviate cytochrome oxidase insufficiency. This suggests that tko is a complex mutant with multiple metabolic effects. Our experience is that the phenotypes (both seizure and age-related) and perhaps mitochondrial function in these mutants is strongly tied to diet and or background and these differences may have created the observed differences. Another interesting finding of this study was that melatonin was able to rescue the tko age-related lifespan and phenotypic effects, but not the ses B age-related defects. Melatonin does not rescue the bang-sensitivity of either mutant. This also supports the idea that tko has broader effects than ses B, which may lead to a number of defects related to both energy and ROS production, but that age-related impacts on lifespan and other phenotypes are not simply due to increased ROS production in mutants.

Summary of characteristics for each bs strain

Table 3
Summary of characteristics for each bs strain
CS/ w1118tkoses Beasjusbss
Seizure phenotypeSTRONGWEAKSTRONGWEAKSTRONG
Shortened LifespanNOYESYESYESNONO
Decreased PhenotypeNOYESYESYESNOYES
Decrease in Climbing AbilityNOYESYESYESYESYES
Melatonin Lengthens LifespanNOYESNOYES
Melatonin Rescue PhenotypeNOYESNOYESYES
AED rescueNO
CS/ w1118tkoses Beasjusbss
Seizure phenotypeSTRONGWEAKSTRONGWEAKSTRONG
Shortened LifespanNOYESYESYESNONO
Decreased PhenotypeNOYESYESYESNOYES
Decrease in Climbing AbilityNOYESYESYESYESYES
Melatonin Lengthens LifespanNOYESNOYES
Melatonin Rescue PhenotypeNOYESNOYESYES
AED rescueNO

Blank indicates Not Done.

Table 3
Summary of characteristics for each bs strain
CS/ w1118tkoses Beasjusbss
Seizure phenotypeSTRONGWEAKSTRONGWEAKSTRONG
Shortened LifespanNOYESYESYESNONO
Decreased PhenotypeNOYESYESYESNOYES
Decrease in Climbing AbilityNOYESYESYESYESYES
Melatonin Lengthens LifespanNOYESNOYES
Melatonin Rescue PhenotypeNOYESNOYESYES
AED rescueNO
CS/ w1118tkoses Beasjusbss
Seizure phenotypeSTRONGWEAKSTRONGWEAKSTRONG
Shortened LifespanNOYESYESYESNONO
Decreased PhenotypeNOYESYESYESNOYES
Decrease in Climbing AbilityNOYESYESYESYESYES
Melatonin Lengthens LifespanNOYESNOYES
Melatonin Rescue PhenotypeNOYESNOYESYES
AED rescueNO

Blank indicates Not Done.

Blank indicates not Done

The eas mutant also showed a decrease in lifespan, worsening of the bs phenotype, and a decrease in climbing ability. From this data, it seems likely that the eas mutant may impact mitochondrial function like tko and ses B. Previous work shows that eas encodes an ethanolamine kinase involved in membrane phospholipid synthesis located in the mitochondria (Pavlidis et al. 1994). Mutants have been shown to have abnormal phospholipid composition, especially in the fly head (Nyako et al. 2001). This mutant has also been shown to have reduced ATP levels although not as decreased as tko and ses B (Fergestad et al. 2006b). Melatonin also rescues the eas phenotype, indicating that the phenotype might be complex as well, as might be expected for a mutant that alters phospholipid composition. Another mutant, enigma, which encodes a mitochondrial enzyme involved beta-oxidation of fatty acids and lipid homeostasis extends lifespan and shows resistance to oxidative stress (Mourikis et al. 2006). These findings suggest that mitochondrial lipid metabolism might be important in proper mitochondrial function.

Both the bss and jus mutants showed some but not all of the characteristics associated with age-related dysfunction. bss showed no reduction in lifespan, although the population did show significant worsening of phenotype and a clear deficit in climbing ability. The bss mutant encodes an allele of the sodium channel and is probably not impacting mitochondrial function, although it does share some of the same characteristics as the tko and ses B mutants. The decline observed in the phenotype with age could be due to a general impact of aging on the nervous system. For example, wild type flies have to observe to develop temperature-sensitive paralysis with age (Reenan and Rogina 2008). The impact of melatonin then could be a general impact on aging in bss. The jus mutant flies did not show many characteristics seen in other bs mutants. The lifespan was not significantly decreased and the recovery time remained unchanged throughout lifespan. Interestingly, jus did show a small decrease in climbing ability with age, although early testing showed climbing ability that was equivalent to the wild type. The results presented here suggest that the bang-sensitive phenotype must arise from a different pathway in these mutants. Further research must be done to find the link between these and the mutants that impact mitochondrial function.

ROS damage in these mutants could be responsible for some of the age-related phenotypes. Our data suggests the all mutants with lifespan and age-related phenotypic decline except ses B respond to melatonin, a known free-radical scavenger. Since ses B has the greatest impact on energetics, its defects may not be amendable to rescue. Previous studies have shown the long-term supplementation of melatonin increased the lifespan of wild type Drosophila by decreasing the amount of unreduced oxygen species within the flies (Bonilla et al. 2002). We see a slight lifespan extension with wildtype in this study, although the effects on lifespan are more profound in tko and eas. Sanz et al. (2010) have showed that mitochondrial ROS production correlates with age, but its role in lifespan has been debated.

Alterations in neural function and reduced climbing ability with age have been correlated with neurodegeneration in the Drosophila (LeBourg & Lints 1991; Fergestad et al. 2006a; Reenan and Rogina 2008). However, there has been some variability in these findings. For example, flies with mutations in K+ channel genes are characterized by increased excitability, neurodegeneration and shorter lifespan in some studies (Trout & Kaplan 1970; Rogina & Helfand 1995) but not others (Fergestad et al. 2006b). Fergestad et al. (2008) reported that bs mutants have a reduced lifespan and exhibit neurodegeneration. Their lifespan findings are somewhat different from this work even with a similar dietary formulation: severe lifespan defects are observed with bss rather than the mitochondrial mutants tko and ses B, and they did not find a lifespan defect for eas. Fergestad et al. (2008) also observed age-dependent neurodegeneration that they described as correlated to in severity to seizure susceptibility and phenotype. In addition, using double mutants between eas and ses B, they found that there was a strong correlation between the seizure and neurodegeneration phenotypes. Our data suggests that bs mutants may have different paths to bang-sensitivity and age-related phenotypes, and in fact the phenotypes are separable. In our studies, age-related phenotypes are not consistently seen with all the bs mutants and are not correlated with bs phenotype.

In mammalian systems, epilepsy has been associated with neurodegeneration in some cases, but not others. Temporal lobe epilepsy, the most common form, is associated with degeneration of the hippocampus. However, in a rat model, neuronal loss is intensified or increases severity of seizures, but was not responsible for their genesis (Zhang et al. 2002b). Kainate acid induced rats showing seizure do not have neuronal loss (Sloviter 1992; Buckmaster and Dudek 1997). AED have been associated with neurodegeneration at human treatment levels in young rats and AEDs have not been shown to rescue neurodegeneration associated with epilepsy (Bittigau et al. 2002).

Our data points to areas where the bs mutants have similarities and differences. We find that mutants associated with mitochondrial function have the most severe age-related phenotypes as expected, even if the strength of their excitability phenotypes is variable. To some extent, antioxidants can rescue age-related phenotypes, except in the case of ses B where viability may be challenged by low ATP levels. Treatments that increase or decrease excitability do not impact these age-related phenotypes, suggesting that they may arise through the mutant’s impact on pathways that are independent of the excitability defect.

Acknowledgments

This work was completed with many Lafayette undergraduates contributing small parts to the larger work. The undergraduates who contributed are: Brooke Keim ‘03, Kyle Klitsch ‘04, Erin Wolfson ’05, Lisa Consensa ’05, Diana Crai ’06, Blaine Caslin ’13, Eugene Warnick ’15, Stacy Nganga ’16, Dan Dellovade ’16, Ashley St. John ’18. Stephanie Cotes also contributed as a technician. This work was supported by a grant from the National Science Foundation #0315527 and Lafayette College.

Footnotes

Supplemental material available at Figshare: https://doi.org/10.25387/g3.6860309.

Communicating editor: B. Reed

Literature Cited

Aksenova
M V
,
Aksenova
M Y
,
Carney
J M
,
Butterfield
D A
,
1998
Protein oxidation and enzyme activity decline in old brown Norway rate are reduced by dietary restriction.
Mechanisms of Aging and Development
100
:
157
168
.

Burg
M G
,
Wu
C F
,
2012
Mechanical and Temperature Stressor-Induced Seizure-and- Paralysis Behaviors in Drosophila Bang-Sensitive Mutants.
J. Neurogenet.
26
:
189
197
.

Benzer
S
,
1971
From the gene to behavior.
JAMA
218
:
1015
1023
.

Bittigau
P
,
Sifringer
M
,
Genz
K
,
Reith
E
,
Pospischil
D
et al. ,
2002
Antiepileptic drugs and apoptotic neurodegeneration in the developing brain.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
99
:
15089
15094
.

Bonilla
E
,
Medina-Leendertz
S
,
Diaz
S
,
2002
Extension of life span and stress resistance of Drosophila melanogaster by long-term supplementation with melatonin.
Exp. Gerontol.
37
:
629
638
.

Buckmaster
P S
,
Dudek
F E
,
1997
Network properties of the dentate gyrus in epileptic rats with hilar neuron loss and granule cell axon reorganization.
J. Neurophysiol.
77
:
2685
2696
.

Celotto
A M
,
Chiu
W K
,
Van Voorhies
W
,
Palladino
M J
,
2011
Modes of Metabolic Compensation during Mitochondrial Disease Using the Drosophila Model of ATP6 Dysfunction.
PLoS One
6
:
e25823
.

Cossarizza
A
,
Salvioli
S
,
2001
Analysis of mitochondria during cell death.
Methods in Cell Biology
63
:
467
.

Feany
M
,
Bender
W
,
2000
A Drosophila model of Parkinson’s disease.
Nature
404
:
394
398
.

Fergestad
T
,
Ganetzky
B
,
Palladino
M J
,
2006
a
Neuropathology in Drosophila Membrane Excitability Mutants.
Genetics
172
:
1031
1042
.

Fergestad
T
,
Bostwick
B
,
Ganetzky
B
,
2006
b
Metabolic Disruption in Drosophila Bang-Sensitive Seizure Mutants.
Genetics
173
:
1357
1364
.

Fergestad
T
,
Olson
L
,
Patel
K P
,
Miller
R
,
Palladino
M J
et al. ,
2008
Neuropathology in Drosophila mutants with increased seizure susceptibility.
Genetics
178
:
947
956
.

Ganetzky
B
,
Wu
C-F
,
1982
Indirect suppression involving behavioral mutants with altered nerve excitability in Drosophila melanogaster.
Genetics
100
:
597
614
.

Grandison
R C
,
Wong
R
,
Bass
T M
,
Partridge
L
,
Piper
M D W
,
2009
Effect of a Standardised Dietary Restriction Protocol on Multiple Laboratory Strains of Drosophila melanogaster.
PLoS One
4
:
e4067
.

Horne
M
,
Krebushevski
K
,
Wells
A
,
Tunio
N
,
Jarvis
C
et al. ,
2017
julius seizure, a Drosophila mutant, defines a neuronal population underlying epileptogenesis
.
Genetics
205
:
1261
1269
.

Kuebler
D
,
Tanouye
M A
,
2000
Modifications of seizure susceptibility in Drosophila.
J. Neurophysiol.
83
:
998
1009
.

Kuebler
D
,
Tanouye
M
,
2002
Anticonvulsant valproate reduces seizure-susceptibility in mutant Drosophila.
Brain Res.
958
:
36
42
.

Kurzik-Dumke
U
,
Debes
A
,
Kaymer
M
,
Dienes
P
,
1998
Mitochondrial localization and temporal expression of the Drosophila melanogaster homologous tumor suppressor Tid50.
Cell Stress Chaperones
3
:
12
27
. 10.1379/1466-1268(1998)003<0012:MLATEO>2.3.CO;2

Kemppainen
E
,
George
J
,
Garipler
G
,
Tuomela
T
,
Kiviranta
E
et al. ,
2016
Mitochondrial Dysfunction Plus High-Sugar Diet Provokes a Metabolic Crisis That Inhibits Growth.
PLoS One
11
:
e0145836
.

Kemppainen
K K
,
Kemppainen
E
,
Jacobs
H T
,
2014
The alternative oxidase AOX does not rescue the phenotype of tko25t mutant flies.
G3 (Bethesda)
4
:
2013
2021
.

LeBourg
E
,
Lints
F A
,
1991
Hypergravity and aging in Drosophila melanogaster.
Exp. Gerontol.
35
:
59
64
.

Lee
J
,
Wu
C-F
,
2002
Electroconvulsive seizure behavior in Drosophila: analysis of the physiological repertoire underlying a stereotyped action pattern in bang-sensitive mutants.
J. Neurosci.
22
:
11065
11079
.

López-Otın
C
,
Galluzzi
L
,
Freije
J M P
,
Madeo
F
,
Kroemer
G
,
2016
Metabolic Control of Longevity.
Cell
166
:
802
821
.

Markwell
M A K
,
Haas
S M
,
Tolbert
N E
,
Bieber
L
,
1981
Protein determination in membrane and lipoprotein samples: manual and automated procedures.
Methods Enzymol.
72
:
296
303
.

Mourikis
P
,
Hurlbut
G D
,
Artavanis-Tsakonas
S
,
2006
Enigma, a mitochondrial protein affecting lifespan and oxidative stress response in Drosophila.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
103
:
1307
1312
.

Nyako
M
,
Marks
C
,
Sherma
J
,
Reynolds
E R
,
2001
Tissue-specific and developmental effects of the easily shocked mutation on ethanolamine kinase activity and phospholipid composition in Drosophila melanogaster.
Biochem. Genet.
39
:
339
349
. 10.1023/A:1012209030803

Parker
L
,
Padilla
M
,
Yuzhe Du
Y
,
Dong
K
,
Tanouye
M A
,
2011
Drosophila as a Model for Epilepsy: bss Is a Gain-of-Function Mutation in the Para Sodium Channel Gene That Leads to Seizures.
Genetics
187
:
523
534
.

Pavlidis
P
,
Ramaswami
M
,
Tanouye
M A
,
1994
The Drosophila easily shocked gene: a mutation in a phospholipid synthetic pathway causes seizure, neuronal failure, and paralysis.
Cell
79
:
23
33
.

Pavlidis
P
,
Tanouye
M A
,
1995
Seizures and failures in the giant fiber pathway of Drosophila bang-sensitive paralytic mutants.
J. Neurosci.
15
:
5810
5819
.

Reenan
R A
,
Rogina
B
,
2008
Acquired temperature-sensitive paralysis as a biomarker of declining neuronal function in aging Drosophila.
Aging Cell
7
:
179
186
.

Reynolds
E R
,
Stauffer
E A
,
Feeney
L
,
Rojahn
E
,
Jacobs
B
et al. ,
2004
Treatment with the antiepileptic drugs phenytoin and gabapentin ameliorates seizure and paralysis of Drosophila bang-sensitive mutants.
J. Neurobiol.
58
:
503
513
.

Rogina
B
,
Helfand
S L
,
1995
Regulation of gene expression is linked to life span in adult Drosophila.
Genetics
141
:
1043
1048
.

Rogina
B
,
Benzer
S
,
Helfand
S L
,
1997
Drosophila drop-dead mutations accelerate the time course of age-related markers.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
94
:
6303
6306
.

Royden
C S
,
Pirotta
V
,
Jan
L Y
,
1987
The tko locus, site of a behavioral mutation in D. melanogaster, codes for a protein homologous to prokaryotic ribosomal protein S12.
Cell
51
:
165
173
.

Sanz
A
,
Fernández‐Ayala
D J M
,
Stefanatos
R K A
,
Jacobs
H T
,
2010
Mitochondrial ROS production correlates with, but does not directly regulate lifespan in Drosophila.
Aging (Albany N.Y.)
2
:
200
223
.

Shah
Z
,
O’Dell
K M
,
Miller
S C
,
An
X
,
Jacobs
H T
,
1997
Metazoan nuclear genes for mitoribosomal protein S12.
Gene
204
:
55
62
.

Shoffner
J M
,
Lott
M T
,
Lezza
A M
,
Seibel
P
,
Ballinger
S W
et al. ,
1990
Myoclonic epilepsy and ragged-red fiber disease (MERRF) is associated with a mitochondrial DNA tRNA(Lys) mutation.
Cell
61
:
931
937
.

Sloviter
R S
,
1992
Possible functional consequences of synaptic reorganization in the dentate gyrus of kainate-treated rats.
Neurosci. Lett.
137
:
91
96
.

Sohal
R S
,
Agarwal
A
,
Agarwal
S
,
Orr
W
,
1995
Simultaneous overexpression of Copper- and Zinc- containing superoxide dismutase and catalase retards age-related oxidative damage and increases metabolic potential in Drosophila melanogaster.
J. Biol. Chem.
270
:
15671
15674
.

Toivonen
J M
,
O’Dell
K M C
,
Petit
N
,
Irvine
S
,
Knight
G
et al. ,
2001
technical knockout, a Drosophila model of mitochondrial deafness.
Genetics
159
:
241
254
.

Trout
W E
,
Kaplan
W D
,
1970
A relation between longevity, metabolic rate, and activity in Shaker mutants of Drosophila melanogaster.
Exp. Gerontol.
5
:
83
92
.

Wallace
D C
,
Zheng
X
,
Lott
M
,
Shoffner
J
,
Hodge
J
et al. ,
1988
Familial mitochondrial encephalomyophathy (MERRF): Genetic, pathophysiological, and biochemical characterization of a mitochondrial DNA disease.
Cell
55
:
601
610
.

Wallace
D C
,
2001
Mitochondrial defects in neurodegenerative disease.
Ment. Retard. Dev. Disabil. Res. Rev.
7
:
158
166
.

Wang
P S
,
Saraswati
S
,
Guan
Z
,
Watkins
C J
,
Wurtman
R J
et al. ,
2004
A Drosophila temperature-sensitive seizure mutant in phosphoglycerate kinase disrupts ATP generation and alters synaptic function.
J. Neurosci.
24
:
4518
4529
.

Zhang
H
,
Tan
J
,
Reynolds
E
,
Kuebler
D
,
Faulhaber
S
et al. ,
2002
a
The Drosophila slamdance gene: a mutation in an aminopeptidase can cause seizure, paralysis, and neuronal failure.
Genetics
162
:
1283
1299
.

Zhang
X
,
Cui
S-S
,
Wallace
A E
,
Hannesson
D K
,
Schmued
L C
et al. ,
2002
b
Relations between Brain Pathology and Temporal Lobe Epilepsy.
J. Neurosci.
22
:
6052
6061
.

Zhang
Y Q
,
Roote
J
,
Brogna
S
,
Davis
A W
,
Barbash
D A
et al. ,
1999
stress sensitive B encodes an adenine nucleotide translocase in Drosophila melanogaster.
Genetics
153
:
891
903
.

This article is published and distributed under the terms of the Oxford University Press, Standard Journals Publication Model (https://academic.oup.com/journals/pages/open_access/funder_policies/chorus/standard_publication_model)